Every parent dreams of handing their child a nest egg to start adult life debt-free. But in the complex world of college financing, your generosity can accidentally become a penalty.
When you apply for financial aid (like FAFSA in the US), not all assets are treated equally. A savings account in your name is assessed differently than an investment account in your child’s name. This is the “Financial Aid Trap.” Thousands of well-meaning parents set up custodial accounts (UGMA/UTMA) only to discover years later that these accounts disqualify their children from thousands of dollars in need-based grants.
Building on our discussion of tax efficiency, this guide explores the strategic side of investing for minors. We will compare the flexibility of Custodial Accounts against the efficiency of 529 Plans and reveal how to build wealth for your kids without sabotaging their education funding.
The “20% Rule”: Why Ownership Matters
The core conflict lies in how financial aid formulas calculate “Expected Family Contribution” (EFC).
- Parental Assets: Usually assessed at a maximum rate of 5.64%. (If you have $10,000 saved, they expect you to contribute $564).
- Student Assets (Custodial Accounts): Assessed at a rate of 20%. (If the child has $10,000 in a UGMA, they expect a $2,000 contribution).
Therefore, every dollar in a child’s name hurts their aid eligibility nearly 4x more than a dollar in your name.
UGMA/UTMA: The Double-Edged Sword
Uniform Gift to Minors Act (UGMA) and Uniform Transfers to Minors Act (UTMA) accounts are the standard “Custodial Accounts.” They allow you to invest in stocks, bonds, and crypto on behalf of a minor.
The Pros: Ultimate flexibility. The money can be used for anything that benefits the child—a car, a laptop, a wedding, or a house down payment. There are no contribution limits.
The Cons: Aside from the financial aid penalty, these assets are irrevocable gifts. Once the child reaches the “age of majority” (usually 18 or 21), the money is legally theirs. You cannot stop them from spending it on a sports car instead of tuition.
💡 The 529 Plan Solution
For college savings specifically, a 529 Plan is superior. Even though the child is the beneficiary, the account is considered a Parental Asset (5.64% impact). Plus, growth is tax-free if used for education. If you are worried about financial aid, prioritize the 529 over the UGMA.
The Secret Weapon: Custodial Roth IRA
If your teenager has earned income (a summer job, babysitting), they are eligible for a Custodial Roth IRA. This is the “Holy Grail” of teen investing.
- Tax-Free Growth: Decades of compound interest tax-free.
- Financial Aid Invisible: Retirement accounts are generally excluded from FAFSA asset calculations entirely.
- Flexibility: Contributions (but not earnings) can be withdrawn penalty-free for any reason, or up to $10,000 of earnings for a first home purchase.
| Account Type | Financial Aid Impact 🎓 | Spending Flexibility 🛠️ |
|---|---|---|
| UGMA / UTMA | High (Student Asset – 20%) | High (Anything for child) |
| 529 Plan | Low (Parent Asset – 5.64%) | Low (Education Only*) |
| Custodial Roth IRA | None (Usually Excluded) | Medium (contributions accessible) |
| Brokerage (Parent’s Name) | Low (Parent Asset – 5.64%) | Total (Parent controls 100%) |
Final Thoughts: Balance Control with Benefit
There is no “perfect” account. If your goal is strictly college, the 529 Plan wins. If your goal is general wealth transfer and you don’t care about financial aid, the UGMA offers the most freedom. However, for many families, simply keeping the money in a standard brokerage account in the parent’s name—and gifting it when needed—offers the best balance of control and financial aid efficiency.
From investing for minors, we move to a sophisticated strategy for adults. In our final investing guide, we analyze the hidden risks of ‘Direct Indexing’ for retail investors with portfolios under $100k.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I take money back from a UGMA account?
No. Contributions to a UGMA/UTMA are “irrevocable gifts.” You cannot take the money back for personal use (like paying the mortgage) without facing legal consequences. It belongs to the child.
What if my child doesn’t go to college?
If you used a 529 Plan, you can change the beneficiary to another sibling, or now (under SECURE 2.0 Act) roll over up to $35,000 into a Roth IRA for the child. If you used a UGMA, the money is theirs to use for a business, travel, or whatever they choose.
Does a grandparent’s 529 plan affect financial aid?
Great news: Under the new simplified FAFSA rules (starting 2024-2025), distributions from a grandparent-owned 529 plan are no longer considered untaxed income for the student. This makes grandparent-owned 529s one of the most efficient ways to fund college.
Be the first to comment